Michail SHELIUBSKY
Vice President of the Aviation Insurance Department
Russian Association of Aviation and Space Insurers

31 March 2016 —
Michail SHELIUBSKYVice President of the Aviation Insurance DepartmentRussian Association of Aviation and Space Insurers
michail_sheliubskyXPRIMM: How much can the aircraft crash in Egypt change the loss ratio in the Russian aviation insurance in 2016?
Michail SHELIUBSKY:
As a result of October's disaster when aircraft А321-200 crashed in Sinai Peninsula, 217 passengers and 17 crew members died and the aircraft was completely destroyed. The risks of aircraft hull and liability were insured by INGOSSTRAKH. At the time being, USD 23 million was paid under aviation hull policy and about RUB 400 million to the relatives of the passengers under the policy of liability.

It is early to speak about the final volume of payments under this accident even if in the future additional compensations are going to be paid to the victims' families. This payment will be significantly stretched in time.

I don't think that in 2016 this disaster will substantially affect the level of losses in the aviation insurance line in Russia, because the most payments were made in 2015. But, even in 2015 the depreciation of RUB against USD affected the growth of the total volume of claims for aviation risks no less than a catastrophe of Airbus: during the previous few years the total payments by the Association fluctuated between RUB 2 - 4 billion, and in 2015 this amount has exceeded RUB 8 billion.

XPRIMM: How do you assess the aviation insurance in terms of rates, GWP and claims?
Michail SHELIUBSKY:
The growth of premiums and claims in the previous year was a consequence of the exchange rate changes, in USD terms GWP decreased and the claims excluding the catastrophe on the Sinai Peninsula remained approximately at the same level.

At the same time, the rates were reduced, which was determined by the excess of capacities on the international reinsurance market, the continuing concentration on the aviation insurance market, and the increased competition among aviation insurers. Only if nothing extraordinary happens, we should expect a decrease of further rates, which has nothing to do with the safety flights.

XPRIMM: The RUB devaluation led to a significant increase in the leasing contracts for Russian companies. How much was this fact reflected in the insurance rates?
Michail SHELIUBSKY:
Really, the RUB devaluation led to a rise in the price of leasing for the Russian airlines operators. In connection with the rates this factor cannot have a significant impact on insurance rates, due to fact that "leasing aircrafts" in accordance with the requirements of foreign leasing companies (note: less net-retention is held by the Russian insurers) are reinsured on the international reinsurance market, which developed by its own laws and, finally, determined the rates.

XPRIMM: Are there any problems regarding the placement of reinsurance of Russian space risks abroad?
Michail SHELIUBSKY:
Regarding the reinsurance of the Russian civil aircraft on the Western reinsurance market we have not detected significant problems. But, in case of losses we cannot completely exclude the possibility of the refusal of reinsurers to pay compensation citing "sanctions" reasons. A few years ago, foreign reinsurers have started to apply the "sanctions" clause (in aviation this is AVN111), which means that even if the loss was recognized as insurance the payments may be delayed until the lifting of sanctions. Many people thought that it was about Iran and North Korea, but it was shown that it concerns Russia as well.

But serious difficulties arise in case of the reinsurance of state aviation, namely military aviation. Currently these risks are placed partially on alternative markets, or through the combined efforts of several companies through coinsurance. The hopes to alternative markets (China, South America, India, and others) are not always justified, as their real capacity is not always sufficient for the reinsurance of aviation risks.

XPRIMM: What are the main challenges on the aviation insurance market?
Michail SHELIUBSKY:
The main challenges of aviation insurers are linked with the state of aviation industry in Russia, which are founded into a structural crisis, characterized by a decline in traffic, large losses, changes in structure of traffic and the structure of cost. During 2015 the crisis grew, especially in the 4th quarter, when the passenger traffic declined by 20%. At the same time, the structure of traffic has been changed: the loss of profitable international destinations and the growth of shares of unprofitable domestic traffic. According to the Federal Air Transport Agency, the total financial losses of the airlines increased by 70% in 2015. Airlines are faced with the closure of transportation programs, the reduction of the number of fleet and the increase in the price of flight tickets.

Thus, we should expect the further concentration of the aviation market, which in turn will contribute to the concentration of the aviation insurance market.

I would link the positive outlook for the majority of the Russian aviation insurers with the hope of ending of the industry crisis due to competent management and state support, as well as the development of new areas and a foreign aviation insurance market.

23760 views