Andres PIIRSALU, Member of Executive Board, Estonian Insurance Association (EKsL), Motor Insurance Bureau and Guarantee Fund (LKF) 14 November 2013

14 November 2013 — Vlad BOLDIJAR
Andres PIIRSALU, Member of Executive Board, Estonian Insurance Association (EKsL), Motor Insurance Bureau and Guarantee Fund (LKF) 14 November 2013
andres_piirsaluXPRIMM: How would you characterize the local insurance market's evolution over the recent semester?
Andres PIIRSALU:
In line with generally positive trends in the economy until the recent news from Northern Europe, insurance business in both life as well as in the non-life side has performed pretty well, when looking at the premium volumes. Compared to half- yearly status a year ago the non- life premium went up by 6 percent and in the life side it grew even by 13 percent. As our market is strongly integrated to the Northern Europe, we are extremely sensible on the trends there, especially regarding the economic performance of Finland and Sweden. As a result it is hard to predict stronger growth numbers in the nearest future in the insurance sector because the situation in the North seems to be a bit "cloudy" right now. In the longer run, however the obligatory pension will boost the total market numbers to totally another level in any case. But for this we still need to wait for another 5-6 years as a minimum.

Having said all the above, regrettably the market performance has worsened in both life as well as in the non- life side when looking at the bottom-line. Half- year profits are the lowest during the last five years in the life side and second lowest in the non- life insurance area. It is difficult to disclose all the reasons at this stage but due to the central online registry in the MTPL, which makes about 1/3 of the market total volume, we can assume that in the non- life up to big extent the reason lies in too low pricing in the market environment, where the loss density still goes down, whereas the average loss level has already stabilized and the costs have increased.

Besides market trends mentioned above we are glad to welcome a new player, PZU, in our market.

When talking about the market developments I would also like to mention, that we have passed another year of success with our insurance dispute mediation body. More than half of all the insurance disputes are handled successfully there. As a result the insurance industry gets: 1) insight to the areas of service improvement; 2) tool for public relations: we can explain the situation about the insurance service quality and it is difficult to attack insurance industry with the unjustified and unfair criticism targeted on the service quality; 3) it is wonderful example of well- working PPP- cooperation. The service is free of charge for the clients and it is very convenient for them, because they do not need to spend on court expenses and it is not necessary for them wait for ages until the decision is made- the problem is solved much quicker and with no cost in the mediation body.

XPRIMM: Which are the major insurance lines at the moment and which hold the highest growth potential in the future?
A.P.:
As already said, the biggest part of the total insurance portfolio is still related to motor insurance, which according to the latest statistics makes 61 % (MOD and MTPL together) of the total gross non- life insurance premium volume. The most realistic boost foreseen in the future for the time being is coming from the second pillar pension in the life and health area, where in a long run the total wolume will grow up to the levels exceeding our current market volumes in times. We expected another strong effect on volume growth- our current government coalition has put the promise in its agenda to launch finally the obligatory Workmens Compensation scheme, but now it seems that this project is not actively dealt with any more. We try to convince them to push the social insurance reform, including Workmens Comp. forward, but with the current coalition the breakthrough is not very probable. The situation with Workmens Compensation looks a bit weird, because in fact we can celebrate 100 years anniversary of the Workmens Compensation insurance in Estonia this year. First time this system was launched already before the Estonia established its independence i.e. in 1913 whereas Estonian Republic was established in 1918. It happened in the era of Russian Czarist Empire already and now, since 1991, when the Estonia got free from Soviet occupation, Estonia is not able to re- establish the Workmens Compensation, which used to be in place already ages ago.

XPRIMM: Except the insurance market, which other industries were affected by the financial crisis?
A.P.:
The crisis is over already for quite some years now, but if to recall these times, there was no industry in place, which did not suffer. Banks practically closed their credit activites nearly overnight completely and such a change must have a strong influence on practically everything. However, these enterprises, which survived, are in much better shape now and well prepared for outside shocks. To give you just an illustration about the effects which took place in the market I have the closest case of course from our area of activity: in the period of 2008-2009 when the crisis was at the highest peak in our area, life insurance lost 50 % of its annual volume and 20 % of the total equity. No any insolvency case took place in such kind of "hurricane season" in the financial sector, but these numbers are quite characteristic to illustrate the amplitudes of ups and downs the external influences may have on our market. No wonder that in this context according to QIS5 study made by EIOPA, Estonia was ranked between the most capitalised markets. But of course there is also another reason for good capitalisation levels, which I can describe further below.

XPRIMM: How much does the retail business represent out of all the written premiums? How did the retail segment evolve over the past few years?
A.P.:
It is difficult to measure the total share of all the clients according to their status because at the moment the only source for such analysis is again the central online MTPL database. However, this source should be quite representative for overall assessment: assumingly most of the policyholders have also a motor vehicle in his/her possession. If to look at composition of Estonian MTPL portfolio, then 11 % of all the clients are legal persons and the absolute majority of the market is formed by private persons in terms of number. In terms of premium split the picture is nearly the opposite.

Credit and leasing activity are driving the market, although the fully voluntary market is gradually picking up too. When the hardest times were over, then first came industrial-commmercial sector, which pushed the volumes back on growth track. Now, more and more also private persons are following the path and right now they are even a main source for growth (on half year 2012 to half year 2013 basis private property premiums are up by 8 %, private motor own damage by 6 %).

XPRIMM: How would you characterize the "alternative sales" insurance business (brokerage / bank-assurance)? What selling-channel dominates the local market?
A.P.:
Sales channnnels can be defined differently. If to follow the traditional meaning of broker service for example, then one can question, whether broker can be classified as sales channel? The same is true regarding the aggregators, which slowly, but surely enter each and every market. In order to be prepared for this change related to the shift of all the private insurance lines to the aggregator channels, Estonian insurers have launched together their own aggregator. It has been up and running for 8 months now and without any advertisement it has attracted about 3 % of the market. It can be accessed on our webpage. It is a classical aggregator, which for the time being gives the client to compare the offers and then go and make the deal with the concrete insurer selected with the assistance of aggregator (i.e. without any mediation). Some broker companies have successfully offered aggregator- like interfaces for long time already. Market share of online brokers is about 25 %. I believe, that one should prepare for the era of aggregators by adjusting the respective business models etc rather than ignoring this general trend. At the moment the aggregator organised by Estonian insurers themselves provides the comparison review only in MTPL, but we discuss currently about expanding it to the motor own damage and other lines thereafter.

Most of the business is at the moment still done by the staff and agents of insurance companies in the non- life side, but banking channels are picking up and the brokers also play important role. In the life insurance due to the specificity of this area, banking channel dominates the market.

XPRIMM: How much does a citizen spend on insurance every year? How did that figure evolve?
A.P.:
If to compare the total volumes against the population number (i.e. insurance density), then the number was the highest during the boom years of 2007 and 2008, when it was pretty close to 300 euro already. Now it is down on the level of 266 euro and strong increase in this number is not foreseen before the changes explained above will take place.

XPRIMM: Many of the large international insurance groups are present in the local market. Why is your market an attractive market for foreign insurers?

It is difficult for me to give full explanation, but I personally could think about three possible reasons: 1) closeness to the Northern Europe; 2) taxation; 3) ease of doing business. Let me explain these reasons in more detail below.

1) Most of the assets are owned and investments are made by our friends from Finland and Sweden. So is most of our foreign trade also related to these countries. Respectively the insurers, to which these investors are used to at their home base, want to be present as well.

2) Taxation is another possible reason: there is no any tax imposed on insurance business in Estonia and the corporate income tax is imposed only in case the money is pulled out of the enterprise in the form of dividends etc. In other words- if profit remains within the company, no tax is imposed on it.

3) Under the ease of doing business I mean relatively straightforward and transparent administrative practices between various businesses as well as in communicating with the public authorities. People are used to work with e- government interface, when they deal with nearly any kind of issue with the public authorities and also e- signature is a tradition in the market- nowadays I sign only the international documents by hand. E- banking, e- tax etc. are part of our ordinary environment and sometimes people get surprised in the abroad, when this all turns out to be much more complicated. Another part of the same effect is related to new services to the public. For instance we, as a private institution, offer wide range of services to the public. For example, as all the data about MTPL losses remains in our central registry, each and every person can check the loss history of any vehicle, he or she wants to buy on our home page. Also geographic view about any particular area in Estonia showing the loss concentration areas and the details of each and every loss, excluding the personal data, is available on our webpage. This is quite popular tool for various public authorities and local communities, when they want to improve traffic safety or plan to develop new roads etc. But at the same time it is also very important tool for the insurance community to step in to the public debates about the safety issues in general- we are taken serious and our proposals to improve the traffic safety are heard by public authorities.

XPRIMM: Are there any major legislative changes to be made in the near future that will target the insurance industry?
A.P.:
Despite few drawback cases like Workmen Compensation, we see few positive changes in the pipeline. In particular this relates to the new Law on MTPL, which is expected to be in force during the first half of 2014, if it becomes accepted by the parliament sometimes during the remainder of current year. In fact the major changes do not change underwriting risk remarkably: we will introduce first party/ own insurer claims settlement scheme for small, simple and typical losses. In addition the business itself will become more similar to any other lines of business from legal point of view- we will reduce some bureaucracy, which is currently in place just because of the specificity of MTPL law.

Key conernstones like very detailed and clear regulation, what concerns bodily injury claims handling and compensation, will remain there and up to big extent will be unchanged. This means, that we continue to keep all the victims served on the fair level because exactly the same principles apply on each and every victim. It also helps insurers to keep the underwriting risk under control. The whole MTPL system continues to work without the lawyers and courts involvement- court disputes are very rare in Estonian MTPL. Less than 0,1 % of all the loss cases and practically none in the area of bodily injury is landing in the court. Compensations are calculated transparently and paid out smoothly on fair and transparent basis. Lump sums are not allowed. The system works very similar to the ones in Finland and Sweden.

20079 views